2020

The U.S. lags in life expectancy, even while spending more than any wealthy country in the world


A research team led by UCLA FSPH faculty found as much as $1.9 trillion of financial waste in the current U.S. healthcare system.

piggy bank and stethoscope

A team jointly led by UCLA Fielding School of Public Health researchers has found the United States fall well behind other countries in life expectancy, while spending the most money on healthcare – nearly twice as much per capita – as other wealthy countries.

“Considering what we get – life expectancy for the dollars spent – do we spend the money in the right places?” asked Dr. Jonathan Fielding, UCLA FSPH distinguished professor of health policy and management and co-author of research published today by the American Journal of Public Health (AJPH). “The answer is no. We spend more, get less, and waste more than every other wealthy country in the world, and administrative costs, fraud and excessive prices do not add anything to a better life.”

Researchers found that depending on the category and type of spending, estimates of the financial waste in the U.S. range from $600 billion to more than $1.9 trillion per year, or roughly $1,800 to $5,700 per American annually. If saved, those amounts could fund huge increases in medical research, disease prevention, food assistance, universal child care, paid family leave, free college tuition and pre-K across the nation, and even a $238 billion middle class tax cut.

“The plot of the current public’s health story, that more healthcare is always better and more expensive is always better, is out of focus. We need a better plot,” said Dr. Steven Teutsch, professor of health policy and management at UCLA FSPH and former director of prevention research at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Good public health and population health approaches and strategies can add more years of life than can medical care, and every wasted dollar in healthcare is one less dollar for public health, schools, jobs, housing, and parks.”

The research was made available this week in a special edition of the peer-reviewed journal, published by the American Public Health Association. The interdisciplinary research team includes scholars from 12 universities and institutions, including Arizona State University, Columbia University, Cornell University, George Washington University, the University of Minnesota, the University of Wisconsin, and UCLA. Co-authors include Frederick Zimmerman, UCLA FSPH professor of health policy and management

The special section includes peer-reviewed research and analysis, as well as editorials outlining issues, potential policy changes, and possible paths forward. These elements include an analysis of opportunity costs, defined as the potential benefits lost when choosing one alternative over another. Because by definition they are unseen, opportunity costs can be easily overlooked, but understanding the potential missed opportunities foregone by choosing one investment over another allows for better decision-making. Among the possibilities suggested by the analysis, which would all be covered by the larger, $1.9 billion estimate, are:

  • Tripling the annual National Institutes of Health (NIH) research budget ($117.6 billion), and the annual budget for research and development (R&D) of the U.S. biopharmaceutical sector ($71.4 billion);
  • Total annual direct and indirect costs of diagnosed diabetes in the U.S. ($245 billion), and the annual estimated costs of the American Housing and Economic Mobility Act ($50 billion);
  • Annual estimated costs associated with switching to 100% renewable energy in the U.S. ($423.9 billion);
  • Universal child care ($42 billion), paid family leave ($28 billion), and double the budget of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) ($68 billion);
  • Free annual tuition across all public U.S. colleges and universities ($79 billion), and free annual universal Pre-K ($26 billion), and
  • Repeal of the estate tax ($64 billion), and a 10% tax reduction to those earning under $200,000 ($174 billion)

These numbers, and options, should make it clear what is at stake absent change, experts said.

“Rising per capita clinical care costs erodes federal, state, and family budgets,” said Mac McCullough, an Arizona State University health economist and co-author of the research. “And it means that less money is available for investments in other determinants of health, including education, job development, housing, environmental issues, as well as necessary infrastructure such as public health—all factors that contribute to better life expectancy in a population.”

In 2018, national health expenditures (NHE) in the U.S. grew to $3.6 trillion, nearly 18% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). The U.S. spends nearly twice as much per capita as other high income countries, but mounting evidence demonstrates that a significant amount of American medical care spending does little or nothing to improve population-wide health outcomes - and is therefore wasteful, the researchers found.

In life expectancy at birth, for example, based on 2019 figures, the U.S. reported 78.7 years; the equivalent in Canada, France, and the United Kingdom was 79, while Australia, Ireland, New Zealand, Spain, and Sweden reported 80, and Japan, Italy, Norway, and Switzerland all reported 81. In infant mortality, the U.S. reported 5.8 deaths per 1,000 live births; Canada reported 4.7, the United Kingdom 3.9, France 3.8, Australia 3.1, Sweden 2, and Japan 1.9. U.S. rates by state varied widely, from 3.6 in New Hampshire, 3.9 in New Jersey, and 4.2 in California, Connecticut, and Massachusetts, to 7.1 in Oklahoma and West Virginia, 7.2 in South Carolina, 7.5 in Arkansas, 7.6 in Louisiana, and 8.3 in Mississippi.

Significantly, the current COVID-19 pandemic has made clear the burdens the current wasteful system puts on low-income and minority groups, as shown by demonstrated shortfalls in health equity measurements, defined as “the absence of avoidable, unfair, or remediable differences among groups of people,” which in turn, imposes excess costs on individual Americans, as well as the U.S. in comparison to the country’s economic competitors.

“The pandemic is forcing a national reckoning over the disproportionate coronavirus-related illness and death in communities of color and other inequities that persist in this nation,” said Dr. Dora L. Hughes, professor at The George Washington University and a former senior advisor with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. “Because of this waste, we do not have additional dollars for investments to improve equity, especially in the first years of life, and we put ourselves at a disadvantage in economic competitiveness: our ability to thrive as a nation.”

The researchers broke down the types of waste as follow:

  • Administrative Waste
  • Excessive Prices
  • Fraud and Abuse
  • Missed Prevention Opportunities
  • Overuse of Clinical Services
  • Clinical Inefficiencies

Specific dollar values, as determined through a variety of studies, methods, and categories, are provided in Tables A1 to A7 of the analytic essay “Excess Medical Care Spending: The Categories, Magnitude, and Opportunity Costs of Wasteful Spending in the U.S.” Teutsch noted that several of these categories (administrative waste, prices, fraud and abuse) do not involve any change in clinical services.

The issue of medical waste is not new, of course; in 2012, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NASEM) published For the Public’s Health: Investing in a Healthier Future, an analytical report by the Institute of Medicine (IoM), now an element of NASEM. Recommendation #1 in the report, setting national targets for life expectancy and per capita medical care costs was recommended because linkage between these two is clear.

“The opportunity cost of a poorly performing, overly expensive healthcare system is detrimental to public health,” said Dr. Marthe Gold, chair of the 2012 effort, a senior scholar with the New York Academy of Medicine, and a contributor to the work published this week in the AJPH. “Traditional approaches to reducing healthcare spending will not enable the U.S. to achieve parity with high-resource nations; strategies to eliminate waste and reduce the demand for low-value healthcare are essential.”

The impact, and causes, of these realities, are illustrated by the idea of an inverted “U,” where additional medical care costs actually decreases life expectancy, authors said.

“Continuously increasing healthcare prices and consequent increase in healthcare expenditures has crowded out spending on public health and important social determinants,” said co-author Dr. Sanne Magnan, with HealthPartners Institute and the University of Minnesota School of Medicine. “Excess healthcare prices reduce resources available to invest in public health and other drivers of health and well-being.”

Sponsorship and Funding: This work was done under the auspices Health Care Expenditures Collaborative from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine. Support was provided by the authors’ institutions.

Data Availability Statement: All relevant data are available via the American Public Health Association.

Citation: Magnan, Sanne; Teutsch, Steven; et al, (2020), AJPH Special Section: “Changing the Public’s Health Story: Reducing Wasteful Medical Care Spending,” etc., American Journal of Public Health, AJPH-202033002


The UCLA Fielding School of Public Health, founded in 1961, is dedicated to enhancing the public's health by conducting innovative research, training future leaders and health professionals from diverse backgrounds, translating research into policy and practice, and serving our local communities and the communities of the nation and the world. The school has 690 students from 25 nations engaged in carrying out the vision of building healthy futures in greater Los Angeles, California, the nation and the world.

Attachments


Faculty Referenced by this Article

Dr. Jonathan Fielding
Jonathan Fielding
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Steven Teutsch
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Jeanne Miranda
Jeanne Miranda
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Galper, Michael
Michael Galper
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Roshan Bastani Headshot
Roshan Bastani
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Samuel Sessions
Samuel Sessions
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Risha Gidwani
Risha Gidwani
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Gerald Kominski
Gerald Kominski
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Michelle Keller
Michelle S. Keller

Dr. Michelle S. Keller is a health services researcher whose research focuses on the use and prescribing of high-risk medications.

Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Alice Kuo
Alice Kuo
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Mark Litwin
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Arlene Fink
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Rosenstock
Linda Rosenstock
Environmental Health Sciences Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Aria Fallah
Aria Fallah
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Daniel Eisenberg
Daniel Eisenberg
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Laura Erskine
Laura Erskine
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Dylan Roby
Dylan Roby
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Aronberg, Sandra
Sandra Aronberg
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. John Lu
Z. John Lu
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Thomas Priselac
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Comanor, Bill
William Comanor
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Leah Vriesman
Leah Vriesman
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Vickie Mays
Vickie Mays
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Lori Pelliccioni
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Neal Halfon
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Robert Brook
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Davidson - headshop
Pamela Davidson
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Felicia Hodge
Felicia Hodge
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Lillian Gelberg
Lillian Gelberg
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Kristen Choi
Kristen Choi
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Warren Scott Comulada
Warren Scott Comulada
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Alan Tomines
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Ron Andersen

Dr. Ron Andersen is the Wasserman Professor Emeritus in the UCLA Departments of Health Policy and Management.

Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Jennifer Wortham
Jennifer Wortham
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Paul Chung
Paul Chung
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Moira Inkelas
Moira Inkelas
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Stephanie Taylor
Stephanie L. Taylor

Nationally recognized health services researcher and sociomedical scientist with 25+ years' experience in effectiveness and implementation research.

Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Yusuke Tsugawa
Yusuke Tsugawa
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Anthony Schiff
Anthony Hunter Schiff
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Annette Maxwell
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
James Macinko
James Macinko

Professor of Community Health Sciences & Health Policy and Management, and Associate Dean for Research

Community Health Sciences Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Avram Kaplan
Avram Kaplan
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Ninez Ponce
Ninez Ponce
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Sangeeta Ahluwalia
Sangeeta Ahluwalia
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Gordon headshot
Thomas D. Gordon
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Kadiyala, Srikanth
Srikanth Kadiyala
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Yvonne Flores
Yvonne Flores
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Michael Ong
Michael Ong
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Olivia Jung
Olivia Jung
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Freund, Deborah
Deborah Anne Freund
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Elizabeth (Becky) Yano
Elizabeth (Becky) Yano
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Jack Needleman
Jack Needleman
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Jose J. Escarce
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Thomas Rice
Thomas Rice
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Image of Dr. Susan Ettner
Susan Ettner
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Isomi Miake-Lye
Isomi Miake-Lye
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Mangione, C
Carol Mangione
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Diana Hilberman
Diana Hilberman
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Nadereh Pourat
Nadereh Pourat
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Emily Abel
Emily Abel
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Emmeline Chuang
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Clifford Ko
Clifford Ko
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Julie A. Elginer

EMPH Academic Program Director with expertise in healthcare marketing, finance, and reproductive health policy, teaching in the EMPH, MPH, MHA program

Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Corrina Moucheraud
Corrina Moucheraud
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Joann Elmore
Joann G. Elmore
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Frederick Zimmerman
Frederick Zimmerman
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Ron D. Hays
Ron D. Hays

@UCLA since 1997

Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Xi Zhu
Xi Zhu
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Robert Kaplan
Robert Kaplan
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Jody Heymann
Jody Heymann
Epidemiology Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Balgrosky headshot
Jean Balgrosky
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Burt Cowgill
Burt Cowgill
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. William McCarthy
William J. McCarthy
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Kenneth Wells
Kenneth Wells
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Paul Fu, Jr.
Paul Fu, Jr.
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Brennan Spiegel
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Arturo Vargas Bustamante
Arturo Vargas Bustamante
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Naomi Zewde
Naomi Zewde
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Patricia Ganz
Patricia Ganz
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
Barbara Berman
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
silhoette
Ty Robbins
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Faculty/staff profile placeholder image
David Hayes-Bautista
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Beth Glenn
Beth Glenn
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile
Dr. Frederick Zimmerman
Frederick Zimmerman
Health Policy and Management
Read Faculty Profile

Related Content

Dr. Tomas J. Aragon
May 30, 2024
CDPH Director Dr. Tomás J. Aragón to deliver 2024 commencement ceremony address for the UCLA Fielding School of Public Health

Dr. Aragón, the California State Public Health Officer, will speak at UCLA Fielding’s ceremony on June 14, 2024

Read Full Article
CHPR_2024_firearms_suiciderisk_thumbnail
April 30, 2024
Access to firearms for Californians aged 15–24 associated with increased suicide risk
Source: UCLA Center for Health Policy Research Read Full Article